Brian Eno is MORE DARK THAN SHARK
spacer

INTERVIEWS, REVIEWS & RELATED ARTICLES
"Craft is what enables you to be successful
when you're not inspired." - Brian Eno

PopMatters DECEMBER 21, 2006 - by Michael Keefe

DAVID BOWIE UNDER REVIEW 1977-79: THE BERLIN TRILOGY

In 1977 disco was all the rage and its simplistic, feel-good vibe, along with the huge success of Fleetwood Mac's laid-back pop/rock album, Rumours, seemed to signal the arrival, or perhaps the numbing, of a mostly placid record-buying public. Even heavy metal was fairly tame during this period. But 1977 was also the year punk rock exploded and the beginnings of new wave began to emerge. This was the galvanizing of an alternative movement that had been burbling under the surface, percolating in different forms in England, the US, and Germany throughout the decade.

Commanding the center of it all was David Bowie. All the music of the era was filtered through him, either via his voracious appetite for new sounds or through his wide influence on his contemporaries and followers. Glam, Iggy, soul, androgyny, Eno, kraut, alien, heroine, Ziggy, thin, white, duke, Reed, rock, Lennon, London, Los Angeles. He passed through it all, and it all passed through him. And all of these people and places and personae culminated in his escape to Berlin and the two 1977 albums he recorded there, Low and "Heroes". This British DVD documentary, Under Review 1976 - 1979: The Berlin Trilogy, is about that pair of amazing twin records and their uneven successor, Lodger, that followed two years later.

The first half hour of this low budget, eighty-five minute documentary is spent, however, building up to its subject matter. Without a doubt, David Bowie's career has always been framed largely by the ch-ch-ch-chchanges he's undergone, each metamorphosis a shifting in style from what he'd presented as his sound and vision during his previous incarnation. It is right, then, that the nameless and faceless crew at Sexy Intellectual should preface Bowie's flight from LA to Berlin with the period just prior to his new adventure. But to devote more than a third of the DVD to Bowie's 1976 output, the album Station To Station and the film The Man Who Fell To Earth, is to greatly overemphasize the importance of each.

Even within the documentary, the conclusions derived by the ad hoc panel of Bowie experts assembled is that, from Station To Station, only the motoric title track could be said to presage Bowie's departure from the plastic soul of his Thin White Duke stage, while The Man Who Fell To Earth's biggest impact on the Bowie of the near future was the contribution of the album cover for Low and the bass line for the track Subterraneans, which was originally intended for use in the film's soundtrack. Appropriately, though, some time is devoted to Bowie's cowriting and co-production efforts on Iggy Pop's pair of great 1977 albums, The Idiot and Lust For Life. Both men were deeply damaged by drug use in 1976, and the trip to Berlin was a joint attempt to clean up together. While this notion seems ludicrous and should have resulted in even greater reinforcement of more debauchery, the clear result was an astonishing period of intensely fruitful productivity.

The sub-subtitle for this DVD is An Independent Critical Analysis, and, true to that, it is structured almost entirely around the expressed opinions of a clutch of British music journalists and musicians. These men (yes, unfortunately, they're all men) vary widely in their abilities to drive the narration. Foul-mouthed and cranky, rock author and former NME writer Paolo Hewitt is hilarious. Composer David Toop, on the other hand, is beyond dull; his meek and depressive nature sucking the life out of every moment of screen time he's given. Fortunately, the perpetually upbeat journalist and musician Chris Roberts helps keep the pace lively, even if it does take a while to get used to hearing him speak extemporaneously with the same syntax and vocabulary usually reserved for the written word of the rock critic.

Mark Pendergrast, author of the fabulous book The Ambient Century, offers fine insight into Bowie's star collaborator during the Berlin years, ambient music pioneer and producing legend Brian Eno. His role in the documentary is, however, overemphasized. Sure, he contributed to all three records, both through some co-writing and synth playing. But this was all under the direction of David Bowie and, in no small part, Tony Visconti, the man who actually produced Low, "Heroes", and Lodger. While the filmmakers make sure to credit Visconti correctly (Brian Eno is often thought to have produced the records), they undermine this by devoting a lot of time to Eno's role, even discussing, in a bonus featurette, his involvement with Bowie again in 1995 (this time actually producing), on the weird, long, dark, and winding Outside. What they somehow fail to mention, though, is that Tony Visconti, too, has since reunited with Bowie, producing his two most recent studio albums, 2002's Heathen and 2003's Reality, which account for the best music Bowie has issued since '80's Scary Monsters. Although kraut rock bands like Cluster and Neu! are given their due on the DVD, Visconti is the man who imbued Bowie's Berlin records with their dense yet rubbery sounds; their springy, rocking paranoia.

Despite these sins of omission and overemphasis, the documentarians and the journalists interviewed here capture well the magical powers of the music contained on the trio of albums at the heart of this film. Mostly, they rhapsodize about the impact, both immediate and to the future of music, of Low and "Heroes". And rightly so. Without the desperate and anxious rock carved out on these records, it would be hard to imagine the existence of many of the great bands who have since emerged, from seminal post-punkers Joy Division to contemporary indie art rockers TV On The Radio. I, too, could rhapsodize all day about this duo of discs, but this has been done elsewhere and in great amounts. I suppose Under Review merely adds to the glut, but it's fun to see these guys getting excited about this excellent music, all the same.

Sadly, they glaze over the subsequent tour, captured on the oft-maligned 1978 live album, Stage, a document greatly improved with its resequenced 2005 reissue. Of great note, super-guitarist Adrian Belew was recruited for this tour, having recently been discovered by Frank Zappa. Flashes of his presence, captured at the Beat Club in Germany, appear briefly in the footage on the DVD.


ALBUMS | BIOGRAPHY | BOOKS | HOME | INSTALLATIONS | INTERVIEWS | LINKS | LYRICS | MULTIMEDIA | SITE | STORE | UPDATES